The Obscenely Simple Question at the Heart of Israeli Politics

M. Gessen / The New York Times
The Obscenely Simple Question at the Heart of Israeli Politics “Some 15 million people live on land controlled by Israel.” (photo: Leo Correa/AP)

I sraeli politics can seem very complicated, what with the many steps, the intricate coalitions, and the often convoluted math required to form a government. At the moment, however, it comes down to one almost obscenely simple question: Is there a force in Israeli politics stronger than anti-Arab racism? The answer seems to be no.

The Israeli parliament, the Knesset, has 120 seats. On Oct. 27, parties that oppose Benjamin Netanyahu won 67 of them. That should have been enough to allow Gadi Eisenkot, who has been tasked with forming a government, to create a solid coalition — but 19 of those seats are held by majority-Arab parties.

Eisenkot, like most other Jewish party leaders, has signaled that he will not include Arab politicians in any cabinet he leads. He would include in his cabinet the Jewish left, or what passes for the left in Israel these days. He would include the right, including the former Netanyahu ally Avigdor Liberman, who has proposed making Israeli citizenship conditional on a loyalty oath. But, most likely, none of the Arab parties. And that is how a simple majority turned into complicated math.

This month, the prominent American-Israeli journalist Gil Hoffman published a column in The Jerusalem Post, a center-right newspaper, offering talking points to Israelis to help them explain the election to foreigners. Why would there be no Arab minister? they might be asked. “It must be explained that this is not because of racism,” Hoffman wrote. “If a minister could deal only with fighting crime and poverty in the Arab sector, there may be no objection,” but, he continued, an Arab cabinet member would inevitably be “relied upon to vote on sensitive security issues” and “the security situation is still too problematic for that.”

That belief — that politicians who are Arab have dual loyalties that make them a security risk — is a matter of political consensus in Israel. Most Israelis, it seems, do not recognize this view as racist, much less an iteration of an age-old antisemitic trope.

Eisenkot seems to be considering two routes. He has been talking to Netanyahu, who has made the case for unity, by which he means keeping himself in power. And Eisenkot has talked about the possibility of an “emergency government.” That may mean a cabinet with the anti-Netanyahu Jewish parties, which hold only 48 seats in the Knesset. Such a government could take power if the Knesset members from the Arab-led parties voted for it despite being excluded from it. Eisenkot could then become prime minister.

A former army chief of staff and a former minister in the Netanyahu government, Eisenkot supports Israeli settlements in the West Bank and opposes Palestinian statehood. In 2006, when he was head of the Northern Command, he implemented what he later explained as the Dahiya doctrine, named for a suburb of Beirut that the Israeli military leveled that year, killing some 1,000 civilians. The Dahiya doctrine, according to Eisenkot, calls for responding to assaults with “disproportionate attacks, including against civilian structures and infrastructure” — more or less the definition of a war crime.

And yet, the Arab parliamentarians will most likely approve whatever cabinet Eisenkot forms, if only to block Netanyahu from his 20th year in power. Such is the price of admission to what most Jewish Israelis believe is a democracy.

Some 15 million people live on land controlled by Israel. About half of them are Palestinians, but only about two million of the Palestinians are Israeli citizens; the rest live in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and must simply wait to be told the results of an election they cannot take part in. On Election Day, I wanted to talk to Palestinians about their relationship to a system that excludes most of them while touting itself as a democracy. I ended up watching Arab citizens of Israel turn out to vote in record numbers.

I planned to spend the day in the occupied West Bank, where Palestinians were watching the Israeli election to see if they’d have any hope for at least a little relief from the terror that settlers, aided by the Israeli army, have been inflicting on them. But then the military announced that it would close all crossings between the West Bank and Israel. (It can do that, even if that means that people can’t get to work or to a hospital.) In the end it closed only some, but people were waiting in lines at checkpoints for hours — even more hours than usual. So I went to the north of Israel instead, to see how people were voting in the Arab towns there.

These towns look markedly different from the majority-Jewish ones. It’s not so much the architecture of the individual houses as the organization of space itself. Houses are clustered impossibly close together. Roads are winding and narrow. Driving seems like a triumph of will over physics and geometry. That anyone can park a car is a downright miracle. Out the train window on the way north, I saw construction site after construction site: white apartment buildings going up on the outskirts of ever-expanding Jewish towns. But Israeli housing policy, construction laws and infrastructure planning all work to keep Arab towns small and crowded.

Recently, the Arab towns in the north have been subjected to threats by settlers who come from the West Bank and set up outposts there. Twelve days after the election, supporters of National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, a settler himself, would march through the Arab neighborhood in the mixed Jewish-Arab city of Lod, in central Israel, declaring, “We came to tell them who the landlords are.”

When Arab citizens of Israel go to the polls, they cannot forget for one second who the landlords are. All the poll workers I saw were Jewish.

In the past 20 years, about half of the eligible Palestinian citizens of Israel have opted not to vote in most elections. It’s not hard to see why. “I do not vote because I refuse to legitimize a system that treats my rights as favors, my safety as optional and my humanity as negotiable,” Nagham Zbeedat, the Palestinian and Arab affairs correspondent for the left-wing newspaper Haaretz, wrote in the paper early this year. On Election Day, Zbeedat was reporting on voting in Arab communities, and I was tagging along with her.

She had written but not yet published a column, she told me, explaining why she wasn’t going to vote this year either. Having Arab members in the Knesset had not helped alleviate anti-Arab policies, she said; it had only lent legitimacy to the government. Back in 2018, when there were more than a dozen Arab members in the Knesset, it passed the Nation-State Law, which essentially enshrined Jewish supremacy.

“I prefer to have a right-wing government rather than a left-wing government,” Zbeedat told me. “The right-wing government will ethnically cleanse and occupy and be racist and they will tell the world what they’re doing with no shame, whereas a left-wing government will do the same things, but with better — with better P.R.”

The day before the election, I attended a hearing at the Supreme Court in Jerusalem. The Toubassi family from the town of Jalud, in the northern West Bank, had been displaced twice in the last few months. After settlers forced the Toubassis out of their house in July, they secured a court order directing the army to help them return home — a rare accomplishment for a Palestinian family. The army did install the Toubassis in their home, as directed, but more than 100 settlers descended on the house. An hour later, the soldiers moved the Toubassis out again. The rioters set the family house and car on fire. Because the area had been declared a “closed military zone,” a Palestinian fire truck could not enter; a military one arrived seven hours later.

The Toubassis were now asking the court for a contempt order against the military. But the Toubassis were not present because they could not get to Jerusalem from the West Bank. The family’s lawyer, Ghiath Nasser, began by expressing his dismay at this circumstance. The military respondents — a deputy commander of the West Bank division, a colonel identified only by the initial A., and a half dozen other soldiers — sat in a single row in the audience, all of them looking down at their phones. Eventually, the colonel testified, acknowledging “shame and failure” of the court-ordered operation to return the family to their home. After some questions from the panel, one of the three justices asked the colonel for advice: “If you were writing the decision, how much time would you allot to rectify the situation?” An activist who works in the West Bank, who was sitting next to me, audibly gasped.

The Supreme Court occupies a stunningly beautiful building in Jerusalem’s government quarter. I’d never been in a courtroom, or any room, like this one, with a vaulted stone ceiling, with the judges’ and lawyers’ tables arranged in concentric curves, and with natural light, bright on a Jerusalem morning but softened by an invisible system of refractions. In 1995, the architecture critic Paul Goldberger wrote, “With the completion of the Supreme Court, Israel, a nation that has shown little architectural leadership, has produced a building that can stand as an example to the world of the potential of public works to reflect a culture’s highest aspirations.”

The Supreme Court building is also one of the few major public buildings anywhere in the world that were designed by a woman. The Israeli architect Ada Karmi-Melamede designed it with her brother, the architect Ram Karmi. This, too, makes the building a kind of perfect symbiosis of form and function. The Supreme Court has enshrined many of the rights — such as freedom of the press, artistic freedom, gender equality, and gay and lesbian rights — that make Israel the modern, Western society it is, for its Jewish citizens. The Supreme Court has also cleared the way for the legal framework of the occupation, and for the disenfranchisement of the Arab minority within Israel.

In the lead-up to the election, right-wing politicians, with support from the left, attempted to get all majority-Arab parties disqualified. Israeli law includes grounds for excluding candidates who do not recognize Israel as a Jewish democratic state and those who support terrorism or present a threat to national security. When the case reached the Supreme Court, all nine justices recommended that Sami Abu Shehadeh, leader of the Balad party, withdraw from the race himself to avoid being taken off the ballot by the court.

At issue was an article in which Abu Shehadeh referred to the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas-led attacks on Israel as an “important historical event.” His opponents argued that the comment amounted to support for armed struggle against Israel. Abu Shehadeh, a historian, is a former member of the Knesset who, it should be obvious to anyone who has read him or heard him, does not support Hamas or approve of its actions in 2023. But Palestinians in Israel have to choose every word with extreme care, while most Jews enjoy genuine freedom of speech. Abu Shehadeh withdrew his candidacy.

In a new book titled “Occupation From Within,” Michael Sfard, a Jewish lawyer who has argued many cases at the Supreme Court, many of them on behalf of Palestinians, writes that it was inevitable that the oppressive and arbitrary legal system created for the Palestinians in the occupied territories would someday expand and seep into the law-based, rights-based system for the Jews. It was this inexorable expansion of the oppressive system, he argues, that brought the nation to its worst political crisis in decades. Since 2023, Netanyahu’s governing coalition has been passing laws that limit the ability of courts to review the executive branch’s actions. (The newly elected legislature has already begun reversing some of this legislation.)

The attempted judicial coup, as Israelis often call it, brought hundreds of thousands of people into the streets. They were outraged by this naked power grab, but not for the reasons Sfard has laid out. They did not make the connection between this assault on their democratic rights and the permanent denial of Palestinians’ rights. They did not protest the occupation. During the demonstrations, they threatened not to show up for reserve duty, but after Oct. 7, many of them reported to their units and some helped carry out the genocide in Gaza. And now many of them still want to get rid of Netanyahu but want to do it without the Arabs.

Some Jews — a tiny percentage, probably in the low single digits — voted for the Arab-majority parties. One person, a former high-level state official, asked me not to write that he was voting for the Arab party Raam, because, he said, this could cause conflict with his adult children. It’s not just his family: The younger generation of Jewish Israelis is much further to the right than their parents — an unusual picture for a Western democracy, the American-Israeli pollster Dahlia Scheindlin told me, “but then again, it’s not a Western democratic country and it is constantly at war.”

The Jewish Israelis who voted for the Arab parties didn’t do it because they thought it would make a difference, exactly. Yuli Novak, executive director of B’Tselem, a human rights organization run by Palestinians and Jews that has published damning reports on Israeli crimes in both Gaza and the West Bank, said, “I can choose between the liberal apartheidists and the fascists among the Jewish parties or I can choose the Palestinians who are trying to play in that field. Of course I’m going to vote for the Arab party.” She said that it hadn’t occurred to her not to vote — as ineffective as the action of voting may seem, it was action nonetheless.

A majority of Arab Israelis must have made a similar calculation. About 80 percent of them voted this time, far above the usual levels. “Do I believe in Israeli democracy?” asked Samah Salaime, a journalist and feminist scholar who is a Palestinian citizen of Israel. “No. But I have a small hope that this government will be gone. Me and my three kids will vote,” she told me. “Maybe that small piece of paper that I put in a box is the last symbol of equality. Jewish, Palestinian, rich or poor,” citizens of Israel “all get one vote.”

Most people on the left are clear about the limits of voting. Novak told me that in the best-case scenario a new government might force a few settler farms to retreat from Palestinian land. But, she said, “even that is hard to see. There would be such pushback that it would be very hard for the new government to do anything about it.” Many of the top brass in the army, the police and the security services have close ties to settler communities. Only a prime minister with strong majority support could dare to confront them (assuming a new leader actually wanted to curtail the settlement expansion in the West Bank), and even on Election Day it was clear that this wouldn’t be the case.

The former official who was planning to vote for Raam stressed that on the most important issue, the Jewish candidates were nearly unanimous. “Even if we win,” he said, “we are not electing leaders who think we did anything wrong in Gaza.”

In the Arab towns, people waited for hours at polling stations. A woman on crutches, with one leg in a cast, advanced toward a polling place at the pace of a few yards a minute. In another town, a man who appeared to be in his 80s rode a mobility scooter down a steep potholed hill. “If he can vote …” Zbeedat said.

She had changed her mind.

We drove to Zbeedat’s hometown. Sakhnin, a city of about 35,000, is particularly important to Arab Israelis. Fifty years ago, Palestinian citizens of Israel organized a general strike and mass protest in response to the government’s plans to “Judaize” — this is the official term — about 5,000 acres of land here, much of which was owned by Palestinian families. The army crushed the protest, killing six people. The appropriation of land proceeded as planned. Every year on March 30, the anniversary of those killings, Palestinians in Israel and elsewhere commemorate Land Day.

A giant military base hugs the road at the entrance to Sakhnin. Its tall fence, topped with razor wire, ends about 10 yards from a school. This was where Zbeedat had gone to high school. “We would hear them practice, we would hear the gunshots, explosions, everything,” she remembered. The town is 20 miles from the border with Lebanon; whenever hostilities escalated, Hezbollah aimed rockets at this military base next door to the school.

Now Zbeedat returned to the school she had entered so many times, to do something that, by age 30, she had never done before. How did she feel? I asked when it was over.

Horrible, she said. Humiliated. She felt that she had done something against her will, “not hoping in the slightest that something will change, that something will get better, only that it will get less worse.” She had spent the last three years — her first years as a journalist — reporting on Gaza, where she has never been, and the West Bank, where she goes frequently. None of the candidates who had a chance at a seat in the cabinet had spoken about curtailing the violence in the West Bank — what we usually call settler violence but what at this point is more accurately described as Israeli state violence.

But, Zbeedat told me, people she knew in Gaza and the West Bank had been begging her to vote. She wasn’t going to be the one to tell them that their last shred of hope was misplaced.

But she could tell me. Take the best-case scenario, she said: The Arab parties get 20 seats in the Knesset. “Even with 20 seats, the parties that will form a coalition will refuse to sit with these 20 because they are Arabs, even if that means they will not have a stable government. They’re willing to risk that because Arabs to them are threats; Arabs are always terrorists.”

She was right. David Zini, the chief of Shin Bet, responded to the success of the Arab Israeli vote by ordering a probe into suspected foreign interference in the election. And when one of the Arab party leaders, Yousef Jabareen, was taking the oath of office in the Knesset, Ben-Gvir interrupted the ceremony, shouting, “Who is he committing to, Hamas?” That same day, Netanyahu gave a speech warning against an alliance with any of the Arab legislators, whom he branded “terror supporters” and “haters of Israel.”

From Sakhnin, Zbeedat went home to Haifa to write a new column, explaining why she had voted after all. I took the train to Tel Aviv, where Michael Sfard, the lawyer, was hosting a gathering (he took pains not to call it a party) to watch the returns. Less than an hour in, he turned off the news broadcast and turned on the music: Gloria Gaynor’s “I Will Survive.”

The mood was anything but festive. The election results showed a clear path to a post-Netanyahu future: an alliance between the Jewish opposition and the Arab-majority parties. “But I’m afraid this country is too racist,” Sfard said. He turned out to be right too.

Please try to be considerate of other posters. Be respectful of everyone's right to express themselves.
Close

rsn / send to friend

form code