Canada Retaliates With Up to 50% Tariffs on Hundreds of US Products
Ian Austen The New York Times
The Canadian flag. (photo: Hermes Rivera/Unsplash)
ALSO SEE: The Potential Economic Fallout of Trump's Trade War With Canada
Canada said the higher levies, on items from aluminum foil to dishwashers to fish, would help protect workers, producers and manufacturers harmed by new Trump tariffs.
As a trade war between the countries intensifies, Canada will start collecting tariffs of 50, 25 and 15 percent on about 700 products beginning on Sept. 8. The most significant measure is a doubling of tariffs on American steel and aluminum to 50 percent. But the list of products affected ranges from household rolls of aluminum foil to railway locomotives and steel bridges.
Many of the American products Canada will now tax mirror the Canadian exports hit by the new U.S. tariffs, particularly in clothing, forestry products, tools and electronics including smartphones. But Canada is also targeting costly consumer products like dishwashers, washing machines and stoves.
A wide array of fish, frozen and fresh, also appear on the list.
The new Canadian levies cover about $20 billion per year of imports from the United States, the same value as the Canadian exports affected by the tariffs.
After the collapse of the negotiations in Washington, Prime Minister Mark Carney of Canada, an economist and former central banker, said that Canada would match the American tariffs “dollar for dollar.” But he also acknowledged that the move “will raise costs and reduce choice for Canadians.”
Mr. Carney left the announcement of the tariffs to several of his cabinet ministers and had no public events on his schedule for Tuesday. He did privately brief the leaders of opposition political parties on the trade situation.
One of the major sources of tension in the trade negotiations was the United States’ 25 percent tariff on automobiles, a major export for Canada, introduced about 18 months ago. On Tuesday Canada said it would keep its retaliatory tariff on American-made cars at 25 percent and maintain a system that allows companies that build cars in Canada to continue to import them from the U.S. tariff-free, within limits. Canadians buy more cars from the United States that they ship there.
On Monday President Trump threatened to double the auto tariff to 50 percent, a rate that would likely doom Canadian car plants, which export upward of 90 percent of what they build. He also threatened to apply that rate to Canadian auto parts, which are currently sold free of tariffs if they qualify as North American-made under the now-shattered free trade agreement among the United States, Canada and Mexico.
Canada imports about $272 billion in U.S. goods a year. Canadian officials said that the government anticipates that it will spend far more on keeping Canadian exporters in business than it will collect from the tariff. The officials, in a briefing for journalists ahead of the announcement, noted that the intention is to protect Canadian manufacturers, not raise money.
Mélanie Joly, the trade minister, said that some of the items on the tariff list were chosen to target states where voters have supported Mr. Trump. She declined to identify the states but said that appliances and “food products” were among those goods.
Many economists say that because Canada’s economy is about one-twelfth the size of the U.S. economy, its retaliatory tariffs will have the effect of a pea shooter in a gun battle. At the same time, most economists say, price increases caused by tariff retaliation will actually harm Canadian companies.
Opinion polls taken before Mr. Trump’s new 50 percent tariffs took effect on Saturday show widespread support among Canadians for economic retaliation. Enthusiasm for the idea has been more mixed among provincial leaders.
Doug Ford, the premier of Ontario, the most populous province and the home to much of Canada’s manufacturing, is a vigorous promoter of retaliation. Danielle Smith, the premier of Alberta, whose oil is overwhelmingly Canada’s largest export, has urged restraint.
Mr. Trump’s tariffs have always excluded oil, natural gas, the fertilizer potash and many minerals.
Economists are skeptical about the effect of import tariffs, but many say that a different tactic could jar the U.S. economy: Taxing exports to the United States of oil, natural gas and electricity, as well as minerals like potash, a key fertilizer. Polls suggest that the idea is even more popular with Canadians than import tariffs as a response to Mr. Trump.
“This is a game of cards,” Ms. Joly said in French “We know we have a lot of good cards in our hand. And we know not to use them right at the start.”
Along with the tariffs, the Canadian government announced a variety of measures to support Canadian industries with exports now under American tariffs. They broadly resemble some of the programs used during the pandemic, like interest free loans. Ms. Joly pointedly and repeatedly noted that they will not require any payments until after Mr. Trump leaves office.