Dems Set Sights on Ice’s Costly Prison Purchases
Brittany Gibson Axios
The Krome detention center in Miami, Florida. (photo: Alon Skuy/Getty) Dems Set Sights on Ice’s Costly Prison Purchases
Brittany Gibson AxiosWhy it matters: Democrats have spent two years furiously writing letters over allegations of ICE and DHS corruption. Starting in January, those letters can turn into subpoenas.
Zoom in: One facility that ICE bought for $495 million in 2026 was offered for sale (but not sold) to the state of Minnesota for $75 million in 2025, according to KARE 11.
- As of mid-November, ICE has paid between $230 million and $739 million apiece for six detention facilities from CoreCivic and The Geo Group, two private prison companies that have garnered major government contracts and record revenue since Trump's return to office.
- The facilities were sold for significantly more than their publicly listed property tax assessments, according to state and local records, and the companies will continue to be paid to operate the facilities.
- Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-N.H.) — poised to chair the Senate Committee overseeing DHS — opened an investigation into the Minnesota purchase. Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.) —poised to chair the House Homeland Security Committee — pledged to investigate contracting and alleged self-dealing.
Between the lines: "There does appear to be a differential between what the property is valued for... and what DHS is paying for," said Art Arthur, a former Republican Judiciary Committee oversight attorney and Oversight Committee staffer.
- "But that in itself is not necessarily indicative of waste, fraud, or abuse."
- "First thing that I would do is I would call in ICE to ask them, you know, what was going on, why this was necessary, and to ask them to respond," said Arthur, now a fellow at the Center for Immigration Studies.
- A Government Accountability Office report in September said ICE's purchases have "the potential to result in waste" and that the agency hasn't "assessed the long-term affordability of owning these facilities."
- Another November report was requested by several Democrats, including Thompson.
The other side: DHS did not respond to questions about these purchases.
- In an emailed statement, a spokesperson said, "The purchase price was set through the standard federal appraisal process. Independent appraisers applied a replacement-cost method, current cost of equivalent secure space, adjusted for depreciation, land, and condition, including the security and fire upgrades required for ICE operations."
- The statement also said that CoreCivic's offer to Minnesota for Prairie Correction Facility "was a preliminary, non-binding indication offered during earlier discussions."
- The Government Services Administration, which manages buildings for federal agencies, said it was not involved with these purchases. The Geo Group did not respond to a request for comment.
- CoreCivic's Public Affairs office said its contracts "are awarded under long-established federal processes, and our real estate transactions follow the appraisal standards that govern federal property purchases."
Zoom out: This spending spree follows an earlier attempt under former DHS Secretary Kristi Noem to own and retrofit warehouses into detention space to the tune of $38 billion.
- DHS has pulled back from that plan, spending just a fraction of that sum, and is now selling most of the warehouses it bought under Noem.
- The ICE detention population has roughly doubled compared to the end of former President Biden's term in office.
What they're saying: "These prices only make sense for an agency that has more money than it knows what to do with," said Claire Trickler-McNulty, who worked at DHS and ICE during the Obama, Biden and first Trump administrations and oversaw ICE detention standards.
- "Taxpayers deserve a public accounting of what the agency gains from owning these buildings, what they will cost to run and maintain over time, and how this fits into any long-term plan," she said.
- But in this political climate, Arthur said, "it may be appropriate and required for DHS to pay a premium for those properties because they need the space in those areas."
The bottom line: "With all due respect to my Republican majority and appropriators, they just let them do whatever they wanted," said Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas), who will lead the House Appropriations subcommittee overseeing DHS.
- Cuellar expects it'll be possible to claw back some of the unspent part of the $113 billion that ICE was allocated — but hasn't been committed — from Trump's "One Big, Beautiful Bill."